A patient in a Facebook group for people with thyroid conditions posts a question about a symptom. Forty people reply, some well, some with doubtful advice. A member tags a doctor she knows. The doctor has a choice: say nothing, correct the record, or answer. Each has costs, and under India's current rules the second and third carry regulatory risk if done carelessly.
This playbook is for doctors in India who are members of, or are invited to, patient-run communities on Facebook and similar platforms, and for the practice managers who advise them. It is a checklist for deciding when to take part and how, with reply patterns you can adapt. It is not legal advice; read the notice itself and consult your State Medical Council or legal adviser for specific cases.
For hospital-run groups, which raise a different set of questions, a different governance framework applies, because the hospital owns the group and its moderation. The rest of this piece concerns doctors participating in groups that someone else owns.
Which rules apply: 2023, 2026 and the 2002 baseline
The picture has three layers, and it is easy to confuse them.
- The 2002 regulations. The Indian Medical Council (Professional Conduct, Etiquette and Ethics) Regulations, 2002 remained the operative code. The Registered Medical Practitioner (Professional Conduct) Regulations, 2023 were published in August 2023 and then held in abeyance with immediate effect until a further Gazette notification, with the 2002 regulations applying in the interim. The 2023 text, including its social media provisions, is therefore not what governs you today.
- The 2026 guidelines. The NMC issued advertising and public communication guidelines on 6 October 2026, effective immediately. Medical Dialogues' report says they prohibit soliciting patients directly or indirectly, including through self-promotion or third-party marketing, bar promotional testimonials and success stories, forbid fake followers and reviews, and permit educational content that does not promote personal practice or solicit patients.
- Your State Medical Council and employer policy. Councils enforce. Hospitals often add their own rules for staff.
When we cover the full notice in our NMC advertising guidelines 2026 summary, the paragraph numbers there are from the notice. Use them when you brief your team.
The line between education and solicitation
A simple working test: does the reply help the reader whether or not they ever become your patient? If yes, it is on the education side. If its main effect is to bring the reader to you, it is not.
| Education (generally acceptable) | Solicitation (avoid) |
|---|---|
| General explanation of a condition in plain language | Offering to see the poster or inviting them to book |
| Pointing to a reliable public source | Naming your clinic, hospital or availability |
| Saying when a symptom needs urgent in-person care | Posting your phone number, WhatsApp or booking link |
| Correcting a factual error about a test or medicine in general terms | Claiming results, success rates or years of experience as a reason to choose you |
| Encouraging the person to talk to their treating doctor | Messaging the member privately to offer a consultation |
| Sharing a guideline from a recognised body | Offering a discount, a free camp or priority slot |
| Declining to comment on an individual case | Asking members to recommend you or leave a review |
None of this prohibits being kind and useful. It prohibits using a vulnerable moment to recruit a patient.
A pre-participation checklist
Before you join or reply in a group, check:
- Who owns the group? If it is run by a hospital, a competitor, a pharma company or a clinic, its purpose may be commercial. Participation can read as endorsement.
- What are the rules? Read the pinned rules. Many groups ban professionals offering services. Respect them.
- Is your identity real and consistent? Use your own profile with your actual name. Do not use a pseudonym or a "patient" account. Posing as a patient to recommend yourself falls under manipulation and fake endorsements the 2026 guidelines address.
- Do you have permission from your employer? A hospital employee may need approval to comment in a professional capacity.
- Are you answering a general question or an individual's case? Only the first is suitable for a public thread.
- Are you at risk of being asked for a diagnosis? Prepare your standard response before you are asked.
- Have you decided what you will never do? See the list below.
Never in a patient group
- Diagnose or comment on an individual's tests, scans or photographs.
- Recommend or change a medicine, dose or brand for a person.
- Offer a private consultation by direct message, or move the conversation to WhatsApp.
- Share patient information, including your own patients' stories, even anonymised.
- Ask for or share testimonials.
- Ask others to tag, recommend or defend you. Do not pay or reward anyone for doing so.
- Post offers, camps, packages or limited-period deals.
- Use a staff member or marketing agency to post as a patient or neutral member. The 2026 guidelines state that using an agency or intermediary does not remove your responsibility for content you authorised or knowingly permitted.
- Comment on another doctor's care.
Approved reply patterns
These are templates for the reply, not scripts to paste. Adapt them, keep your wording consistent and have a colleague or your hospital's compliance lead review them. All are hypothetical.
Pattern 1: A general educational answer
I am a physician, so I can speak in general terms but not about your case. In general, [one or two sentences of widely accepted information]. This is general information, not advice for any one person. Please discuss your symptoms with your treating doctor.
Use it when a member asks a general question: what a test measures, how a condition is usually monitored. Keep it to what you could cite from a recognised guideline, and link the source.
Pattern 2: A request for an individual opinion
I am sorry you are dealing with this. I cannot give an opinion on an individual case in a public group, and it would not be safe to try without examining you and seeing your records. Please speak to the doctor treating you, and if you are unsure, ask for a second opinion from a doctor you trust.
Notice what this does not do: it does not say "visit my clinic".
Pattern 3: Red-flag symptoms
What you describe can sometimes need urgent assessment. Please do not wait for replies here. Contact your doctor now or go to the nearest emergency department.
Have your clinical sponsor or a colleague agree this wording ahead of time. Use it without elaboration.
Pattern 4: Correcting misinformation
Thank you for raising this. The guidance from [named recognised body, with link] is that [correct information]. Individual situations differ, so please check with your treating doctor before changing anything.
Correct the claim, not the person. Do not name products or brands, and do not criticise another doctor.
Pattern 5: Someone asks you directly to take them on
I am glad you asked, but I am not able to take on patients through this group. Your treating doctor or your local hospital can arrange a referral if you need one.
You may be tempted to give a clinic name. Do not. If the member can find you through your normal public listings, that is separate from you promoting yourself in the thread.




