This post is for hospital CFOs, international patient desk heads and marketing leads who must decide how much of their international patient flow should come through facilitators and how much through direct marketing. It is a comparison, not an argument for one side. Both models work when they are priced and governed properly, and both fail in predictable ways.
The method below puts the two on the same cost-per-arrived-patient footing, then adds the things that a simple commission-versus-ad-spend comparison hides: control of the patient relationship, attribution, concentration risk and compliance exposure. It uses hypothetical numbers, clearly labelled, because we do not publish benchmarks that we cannot source. Substitute your own.
Our broader medical tourism marketing guide and foreign patient playbook cover the programme; this post covers the economics of one decision inside it.
Define the unit: cost per arrived, treated, paid patient
Marketing teams often measure cost per enquiry. Facilitators are paid on cost per treated patient. To compare, convert both to one unit: cost per arrived and billed patient, where "billed" means the case produced revenue for the hospital after discounts and write-offs.
For direct acquisition, the numerator is everything you spend: ads, content, agency fees, translation, tools, the international desk's salary share and any payments to interpreters or pickup partners. The denominator is arrived and billed patients that your data attributes to direct channels.
For facilitators, the numerator is commission and any discounts you give the facilitator, plus the desk's time spent on facilitator cases. The denominator is arrived and billed patients that came through them.
Include the desk's salaries on both sides. Teams that exclude them make direct look cheaper than it is, and then wonder why the desk is overloaded.
A worked hypothetical
The numbers below are invented for illustration. They describe a hypothetical 300-bed hospital in a metro city that is deciding where to place its next unit of effort.
| Item | Facilitator route | Direct route |
|---|---|---|
| Enquiries per quarter | 120 | 200 |
| Enquiries that reach a quote | 60 | 70 |
| Quotes that convert to arrival | 30 | 21 |
| Average billed per arrived patient (₹) | 4,00,000 | 4,00,000 |
| Commission or marketing cost per quarter (₹) | commission at one-fifth of billing = 24,00,000 | 12,00,000 |
| Desk cost allocated (₹) | 3,00,000 | 6,00,000 |
| Total cost (₹) | 27,00,000 | 18,00,000 |
| Cost per arrived patient (₹) | 90,000 | 85,714 |
On these numbers the two routes are within a few per cent of each other per arrived patient, which is the realistic message of most such models: the headline commission rate does not decide the economics. Conversion from quote to arrival, the revenue per patient and the desk's workload do. A facilitator that converts more quotes can justify a higher fee; a direct programme that attracts patients for lower-value procedures cannot.
Run the same table with your own figures for the last four quarters. If you have fewer than 20 arrived patients per route, treat the result as indicative only.
Four dimensions that a spreadsheet misses
Commission structure
Facilitators are typically paid a percentage of the bill, a fixed fee per patient or a hybrid. Each structure creates a behaviour.
- Percentage of bill rewards pushing higher-value treatment and can create friction if your clinicians recommend a smaller procedure.
- Fixed fee per arrival keeps incentives neutral but may reduce effort on complex cases.
- Hybrid with a payment tied to completed treatment protects against cancelled cases.
Write the commission base clearly: before or after discounts, including or excluding pharmacy and consumables, and when it becomes payable. Disputes usually begin with a bill that changed after discharge.
Control of the patient relationship
With a facilitator, the first conversations may happen outside your systems. You may not know the patient's real budget, what they were promised or what language was used. With direct, you control the message and can correct a misunderstanding early.
The question to ask is: who tells the patient what the treatment and cost may involve? Whoever does owns the expectation. Require that every written estimate is issued or approved by your hospital, and that medical statements come only from your clinicians.
Attribution
Attribution is where facilitator models become opaque. A patient may have seen your Google ad, visited your site, then contacted a facilitator who also advertises you. Two channels will claim the case. Decide the rule in advance: for example, the channel that sent the first record-bearing enquiry owns the case for a defined window. Store source and window in your CRM so the decision can be audited. A CRM set up to track patients makes this practical; if you need a walkthrough of how enquiry ownership and pipeline can be tracked in one place, Pioneer CRM can be seen at /demo.
Risk
Risk comes in several forms:
- Concentration. One facilitator controlling a large share of a nationality's flow can raise fees or move to a competitor.
- Reputation. The patient blames the hospital for the facilitator's behaviour.
- Compliance. Payments linked to patient referrals can create exposure under professional conduct rules, advertising rules or anti-corruption law in India or the patient's country. Get legal advice on structure and disclosure before signing. Our compliance overview lists the market-specific frameworks we track.
- Data protection. Sharing identity documents and medical records with an intermediary requires a clear purpose, minimal access and a data-handling clause.
Failure modes
The facilitator "buys" your brand. They bid on your hospital name in search and charge commission for patients who would have come anyway. Monitor brand search results and prohibit brand bidding in the contract.
The quote that changes. The facilitator quotes low to win the patient, and the hospital's real estimate is higher. The patient blames you. Fix by requiring hospital-issued estimates.
Direct without a desk. The programme generates enquiries but no one replies for two days. Fix with a first-response standard and staffing sized to the enquiry volume.
Attribution wars. Marketing and the international desk each claim cases. Fix with the rule above and a monthly reconciliation.
Single-nationality dependence. The programme works until a visa or policy shift removes the market. Fix by tracking concentration, as discussed in our posts on neighbouring and African source markets.




