Skip to main content
NewNMC’s advertising guidelines for doctors are in force from 6 Oct 2026. See what to change, and get a free compliance auditNew NMC advertising rules for doctors: what to change
SEO

A YMYL Content Audit Template: Scoring 200 Health Pages for Trust Risk

A scorecard and triage matrix for auditing 200 health pages for trust risk: claims, sources, reviewer, dates, outcome promises and intent fit, ending in keep, rewrite, merge or remove.

A YMYL Content Audit Template: Scoring 200 Health Pages for Trust Risk

A hospital with six years of blogging usually has somewhere between a few hundred and a few thousand health pages. Nobody has read them all since they were published. Some were written by an agency, some by a consultant's assistant, some are leftovers from a migration. A few make claims that the hospital's own compliance lead would not approve today.

This article is for marketing leads, SEO managers and content heads who have been asked to "clean up the health content" and need a defensible way to do it. It gives you a scorecard for six risk dimensions, a method for scoring a sample of 200 pages, and a triage matrix that turns scores plus Search Console data into one of four actions: keep, rewrite, merge or remove. It is a working template. The clinical judgements stay with the clinicians who review the flagged pages.

The reason to score at all, rather than just delete thin pages, is that the pages that pose the most risk are often not the thin ones. A long, well-ranked article with an unreferenced dosage statement or an implied cure is more dangerous than a short outdated one. Google's guidance on helpful, reliable content and its Search Quality Rater Guidelines both put health among topics where trust matters most, and an audit should look for trust problems, not only for length.

Scope: what counts as a YMYL health page

"Your Money or Your Life" content is content that could affect a person's health, safety, finances or wellbeing. For a hospital site that means condition pages, symptom pages, treatment and procedure pages, drug and test pages, cost pages, and any blog post that gives guidance on health decisions. It does not usually include a careers page or a parking map.

Start from a crawl of the whole site, filter to the clinical sections, and then draw your 200. If the site has fewer than 200 such pages, score all of them. If it has thousands, take a stratified sample, with proportionate numbers from each specialty and each content type, plus every page in the top tier by clicks. The aim is a picture of the whole site you can act on, not a perfect census.

Our overview of E-E-A-T for healthcare websites explains the framework; this article is the operational template that follows from it.

The scorecard: six dimensions

Score each page from 0 to 2 on each dimension, where 0 is a clear problem, 1 is partial and 2 is sound. Define each level in writing before anyone scores a page, so two auditors would reach the same number.

Dimension012
1. ClaimsSpecific clinical claims with no support, or claims beyond the evidenceMostly supported, with some vague or generalised statementsEvery clinical claim is qualified, supported and within scope
2. SourcesNo sources, or only weak ones (news, brand pages)Some primary sources, not mapped to claimsPrimary sources mapped to claims, current and checkable
3. ReviewerNo named author or reviewerAuthor named, no clinical review shownNamed clinical reviewer with credentials and a review date
4. DatesNo date, or a date that conflicts with the contentPublished date only, or old with no reviewPublished and reviewed dates visible and plausible
5. Outcome promisesPromises, guarantees or comparative superiorityAmbiguous language such as "best results"None; limits and uncertainty acknowledged
6. Intent fitPage does not answer the query it ranks forPartly answers, with padding or tangentsAnswers the intent and routes the reader to a sensible next step

A seventh column of facts, not scores, goes beside them: URL, specialty, page type, word count, clicks and impressions over a fixed period, linked conversions if tracked, the number of other pages targeting the same query, and the date of the last substantive edit.

Critical flags that override the total

Some findings should trigger action no matter how well the page scores elsewhere. Give them their own column:

  • A guarantee, cure claim or implied outcome.
  • A dosage, self-medication or self-treatment instruction without a cited, approved source.
  • Content that contradicts the hospital's current clinical practice.
  • A patient identifiable from text, image or testimonial without clear consent.
  • A statement that appears to breach advertising rules for doctors or hospitals. In India the NMC advertising guidance is the reference we use with clients; confirm against the regulator's own text.
  • A named doctor who has left the institution, still shown as the reviewer or treating physician.

A critical flag sends the page to the clinical lead and compliance lead for a decision within an agreed period, and the page is edited or taken down while that happens if the flag is serious.

Running the audit on 200 pages

Set up. Build a spreadsheet with one row per page and the columns above. Pull Search Console data for a fixed period (the longest you have, up to 16 months), and join it to the crawl by canonical URL. The Performance report can export queries and pages, and the Search Console API can export larger sets.

Calibrate. Have two auditors score the same ten pages independently. Compare the results, discuss every disagreement and tighten the definitions. Repeat until scores agree on nearly all pages. Skipping calibration is the most common reason audits cannot be defended later.

Score. At roughly ten minutes a page, 200 pages is around 33 hours of work, so divide it between two auditors and give a clinician a defined slice of flagged pages, not the whole set. Score the first read quickly, and record a note for every 0.

Verify. Pick twenty scored pages at random and have a second person re-score them. If the totals differ by more than a point on many, recalibrate.

Review with clinicians. Send the critical-flag pages and the lowest-scoring pages to the relevant specialty reviewer. Bundle them by specialty so a consultant reviews related pages together.

Want this applied to your practice? Get a free seo audit.

Book my free audit

From score to decision: the triage matrix

Combine the total risk score with a page's value. Value comes from search visibility (clicks and impressions), conversions, internal and external links, and whether the page is the only one covering a topic.

Low risk (high score)High risk (low score)
High valueKeep and maintain. Add reviewer or dates if missing; schedule review.Rewrite urgently. Clinician review first; preserve the URL.
Low valueKeep, merge or leave. Merge if it duplicates another page; otherwise leave alone.Remove or merge. Redirect or retire; do not invest in a rewrite.

Then apply the specific rules.

Rewrite when the topic matters to patients and the hospital, the page has some visibility, and the problems are fixable: missing sources, no reviewer, outdated dates, weak intent fit. Rewrite on the same URL so any history carries over. The rewrite follows the full draft, clinical review, source check and publish workflow.

Merge when two or more pages answer the same intent. Use Search Console to find query overlap: where several URLs receive impressions for the same queries, that is cannibalisation. Our glossary entry on keyword cannibalization explains it. Pick the strongest URL, fold the best content into it, and 301 redirect the others to it.

Remove when the page has little or no value, cannot be fixed economically, or is wrong. If an equivalent page exists, 301 redirect to it. If the topic has no equivalent and the content should not exist, return a 404 or 410 status. Do not redirect unrelated pages to the homepage as a blanket measure; that tends to confuse users and search engines.

Keep when the page scores well. Add it to the review calendar and move on.

Be clear about the objective. The audit reduces trust risk and improves the quality of what you publish. It is not a guaranteed way to raise rankings, and deleting pages does not by itself improve a site's performance. Record the decisions and their dates so you can compare outcomes later without telling yourself a story.

A worked example, with hypothetical numbers

Take a hypothetical 150-bed hospital site with 200 clinical pages. After scoring, the picture might be as follows. These numbers are invented to show how to read the output, not benchmarks.

GroupPagesWhat the data saysAction
Critical flags9Mixed scores; some highly visibleClinical and compliance review this week
High value, low score31Visible, no reviewer, old datesRewrite in order of visibility
Low value, low score58Little traffic, thin or outdatedMerge or remove
Duplicates24Several pages per conditionMerge into one per intent
Sound78Good scoresCalendar review

Note that the groups overlap: a page can be both duplicate and low score. Resolve each page to a single primary action and record secondary issues in the notes. The point of the exercise is the shape: usually a small number of urgent pages, a middle group that needs rewriting, and a large tail that should be merged or removed.

Plan capacity from this table. Thirty-one rewrites at a full four-stage review may take a quarter. If so, say that at the start and sequence by risk first and visibility second.

Maintaining the scorecard

An audit is a snapshot. Turn it into a routine:

  • Re-score the top tier of pages every six months.
  • Score every new clinical page before publishing, using the same six dimensions.
  • Add a trigger list for out-of-cycle reviews: a guideline revision, a drug approval or withdrawal, a price change, a clinician leaving or a regulator's announcement.
  • Keep the audit sheet as a living register and connect it to the content calendar.

Our healthcare SEO audit service and the free healthcare SEO audit tool cover the technical side; this scorecard covers the trust side that technical audits miss. The patient education content strategy and the piece on Google's helpful content update explain the editorial principles behind the criteria.

Checklist

  • Define the six dimensions and their 0 to 2 levels in writing.
  • Add a critical-flags column and a named owner for each flag type.
  • Build the sheet from the crawl, Search Console and, where available, conversion data.
  • Calibrate with two auditors on ten pages before scoring the rest.
  • Score, then re-score a random twenty.
  • Route flagged and low-scoring pages to clinicians in specialty bundles.
  • Resolve each page to one action: keep, rewrite, merge or remove.
  • Use 301 redirects for merges and removals with an equivalent, and 404 or 410 where none exists.
  • Log decisions and dates, then re-measure after a full quarter.
Filed underYMYL content audithealth content audit templatemedical content audit checklistcontent audit scorecardhospital blog auditcontent triage merge delete

About the author

Co-Founder & CTO · Gurugram, India

Arush builds the systems the rest of the company runs on — the patient-acquisition pipelines, the AI chatbots, the analytics that tie a single click to a booked appointment. If a campaign reports a number, it's because something his team built is tracking it.

Free guide · 15 pages

The Patient Acquisition Blueprint

A 90-day plan from first search to booked appointment.

The Pioneers Brief — one essay, three benchmarks, one teardown, every Thursday. Subscribe free →

Free seo audit

Your next chapter starts with a conversation.

Three quick questions. We come prepared with a plan for your specialty and city.

  • A 30-minute call with a healthcare specialist
  • Your top three growth opportunities, in writing
  • Honest advice — even if that means not hiring us
  • No obligation and no hard sell
You’ll speak with a senior strategist
Consultations are hosted by Arush Thapar’s team.
Step 1 of 3Takes 30 seconds

What do you want to improve first?

Details stay privateNo obligationReply within 1 working day

Client portfolio · Healthcare websites

Work relevant to a ymyl content audit template scoring 200 health pages for trust.

Explore client work →