Skip to main content
NewNMC’s advertising guidelines for doctors are in force from 6 Oct 2026. See what to change, and get a free compliance auditNew NMC advertising rules for doctors: what to change
SEO

What the Search Quality Rater Guidelines Actually Say About Medical Pages

A close reading of Google's rater guidelines on YMYL, trust, reputation and the Lowest rating, mapped to the pages an Indian hospital actually publishes, with a method to audit them.

What the Search Quality Rater Guidelines Actually Say About Medical Pages

This post is for the marketing lead or SEO owner of a hospital group or large clinic who has heard "follow the rater guidelines" in a vendor pitch and never read the document. It is advanced in the sense that it assumes you already know what E-E-A-T stands for. Our earlier piece on E-E-A-T for healthcare websites covers the concept. This one reads the actual wording of the guidelines and shows what each passage implies for a hospital website.

Two cautions first. The guidelines are written for human raters who evaluate search results. Google says their feedback helps it test and evaluate changes to Search; a rater does not sit on your page and set its ranking. Treat the document as the clearest public statement of what Google wants its systems to approximate, not as a checklist that moves positions. Second, the quotes below come from the September 2025 edition of the General Guidelines PDF. Google revises it, so check the date on the current edition before you build a process on it.

How the guidelines define a medical page as YMYL

Section 2.3 defines "Your Money or Your Life" topics as those that could significantly affect health, financial stability, safety or the welfare of society. Health is the first category. The document explains that a topic is YMYL when it "could cause harm if the content is not accurate and trustworthy", and gives "symptoms of a heart attack" as one of its own examples. It also describes YMYL as a spectrum, with pages on clear YMYL topics receiving "the most scrutiny".

For a hospital, that is every clinical page: condition explainers, treatment pages, doctor profiles, cost pages, even a "what to expect on the day" article. The guidelines go further elsewhere and say that "medical search results should be high quality, authoritative, and trustworthy". The practical consequence is that you cannot treat the blog as lower-stakes than the service pages. A rater looking at a 600-word post on chest pain applies the same standard as one looking at the cardiology department page.

Trust sits at the centre, and the other three feed it

Section 3.4 puts Trust at the centre of E-E-A-T and defines it as the extent to which a page is "accurate, honest, safe, and reliable". Experience, Expertise and Authoritativeness are described as concepts that support the judgement of Trust. The document is blunt about the ordering: "untrustworthy pages have low E-E-A-T no matter how Experienced, Expert, or Authoritative they may seem."

Google's own helpful content guidance repeats the point for site owners: of the four aspects, trust is the most important, and the others contribute to it.

For a hospital this changes where to spend effort. A department page with ten consultant photographs and a list of awards does not rescue a page that gives no information about who reviewed it, when, or who is responsible for the site. Accuracy and honesty come first.

Three sources of evidence a rater is told to use

The same section tells raters to form their E-E-A-T judgement from three places:

  • What the site says about itself, starting with the About page or the author's profile.
  • What others say about the site or creator: independent reviews, references, news articles and other credible sources.
  • What is visible on the page itself, including the main content and any reviews or comments.

Section 3.3 adds that reputation research is "required for all PQ rating tasks", and is to be done according to the topic. For medical content that means researching the site's and creator's reputation for medical information specifically. The text tells raters to "be skeptical of claims that websites make about themselves, particularly when there is a clear conflict of interest", and that for YMYL topics, reputation "should be judged by what experts in the field have to say". Recommendations from "professional societies" count as strong evidence.

Read that against a typical hospital site. The About page says "India's most trusted hospital". The guidelines tell the reader to discount that sentence and look elsewhere. We return to this in the mapping table below, and the off-site side of it is a separate exercise: the off-site sweep below is the companion exercise to the on-site audit.

What puts a medical page at Lowest

Section 4 is the one hospital teams should read twice. The Lowest rating covers pages that are harmful, untrustworthy or spammy. Several of the listed triggers are mundane and entirely avoidable:

  • A page "designed to deceive people about its true purpose or who is responsible for the content on the page".
  • "Inadequate information about the website or content creator for the purpose of the page". One worked example is a medical site with "literally no information about who is responsible for the content or the website", and the explanation says that medical pages require a high level of user trust.
  • Deceptive authorship. The deception section lists "fake" owner or creator profiles, including "AI generated content with made up 'author' profiles", and false claims of credentials, with the example of a creator claiming falsely to be a medical professional.
  • Content that contradicts "well-established expert consensus" on a YMYL topic.

On the other side, the Low rating examples include a flu article where "there is no evidence that the author has medical expertise", and the document says that lacking expertise on a YMYL topic is a reason for a Low rating. The Highest examples include health information on a hospital page whose positive reputation is evidenced by independent sources.

Note what is not in these lists: word count, keyword placement, or the number of doctor photographs. The failures are about identity, accountability and accuracy.

Want this applied to your practice? Get a free seo audit.

Book my free audit

Mapping the language to an Indian hospital website

The table translates the guideline concepts into what you can inspect on a typical hospital or large-clinic site in India. The "common gap" column is a set of patterns to look for, not a finding about any named hospital.

Guideline conceptWhat a rater looks forEvidence to put on an Indian hospital pageCommon gap to check
Who is responsible for the site (2.5.2)A clear owner and a way to contact themLegal entity name, registered address, clinical establishment details, working phone and email in the footer and on a Contact pageBrand name only; contact is a form with no address
Who created the content (2.5.2)A named creator with backgroundByline linking to a doctor profile with qualifications and registration number"Admin" or "Team" bylines on clinical posts
Expertise on YMYL topics (3.4)Evidence the creator has the knowledge for the topicReviewer's specialty matching the page topic; a review dateGeneric reviewer, or a surgeon reviewing a topic outside their field
Accuracy against expert consensus (3.2)Content consistent with established medical guidanceCitations to guidelines, journals and government health bodiesClaims with no source; outdated screening intervals
Reputation (3.3)Independent sources, expert and professional recognitionAccreditation status that can be verified, press and academic mentionsAwards listed with no awarding body or year
Deceptive creator information (4.5)No fake profiles or inflated credentialsReal clinicians with verifiable registrationsStock-photo "doctors", AI-written bios
Main content satisfies the purposeThe page answers the query it targetsPage type matched to intent: condition, procedure, cost, doctorA 300-word city landing page with a template paragraph

A hospital in India also has a regulatory overlay on the doctor-facing items. The National Medical Commission's October 2026 advertising notice asks for names, qualifications and registration numbers where practitioners are identified, and it restricts superlatives and promotional portrayal of individual doctors. The NMC compliance handbook and the NMC guidelines hub explain how to present credentials as factual information rather than self-promotion. The rater guidelines and the NMC notice point the same way here: verifiable facts, no inflated claims.

A method to audit your own pages

We do not publish results here, because the exercise has to be run on your own data. The method takes about two working days for a mid-sized site.

Step 1. Build the sample. Pull the top 300 URLs by clicks from Search Console over the last three months. Add 30 URLs that get impressions but few clicks. Classify each as condition, procedure, cost, doctor, department, location, news or other.

Step 2. Crawl for the evidence fields. Use a crawler with custom extraction to record, per URL: byline present; byline linked to a profile; reviewer present; reviewer specialty; visible last-reviewed date; count of external citations; presence of About, Contact and editorial policy links in the footer; presence of an author registration number. Record yes or no, not quality judgements.

Step 3. Score with the guideline questions. For each page type, a human reads ten pages and answers four questions: Who is responsible? Who made this? Would a clinician in this specialty recognise the content as consistent with accepted practice? What would an independent source say about this site? Mark each as clear, partial or absent. Have the clinical reviewer do the third question, not the marketer.

Step 4. Join with Search Console. Compare, by page type, the evidence fields against clicks and impressions. You are looking for patterns, such as condition pages without reviewers underperforming condition pages with them. Do not infer causation from one export. Treat each pattern as a hypothesis, then change a batch of pages and watch the same queries for several weeks, remembering that core updates can move things for unrelated reasons.

Step 5. Fix in order of risk. Anything that would read as deceptive comes first: invented bylines, inflated credentials, unverifiable awards. Missing About and contact information is second. Review dates and citations are third. Rewriting prose comes last.

Common misreadings to avoid

  • "Raters decide rankings." They do not rate your live pages for ranking. Do not chase the language of the document in page copy; the documents describe what trustworthy pages are, not phrases to include.
  • "E-E-A-T is a score." Google's guidance describes it as a mix of factors its systems use to identify helpful, trustworthy content. There is no number to optimise.
  • "More doctors on the page means more expertise." Expertise is judged relative to the topic. A single reviewer in the right specialty beats a gallery of unrelated consultants.
  • "Schema fixes trust." Structured data can express authorship and review, and is useful. See schema.org MedicalWebPage for the reviewedBy and lastReviewed properties. It only helps if the visible page says the same thing and the facts are true.

Where to start

  1. Read sections 2.3, 2.5.2, 3.3, 3.4 and 4.5 of the current guidelines. It is about fifteen pages.
  2. List every clinical page type on your site and decide who is the accountable reviewer for each.
  3. Add visible ownership and contact information to the footer, and a real About page.
  4. Replace anonymous clinical bylines with named, registered clinicians, or with a named editor plus a named clinical reviewer, as your own legal advice allows.
  5. Run the five-step audit above on a sample before touching the full site.

If you want help setting up the crawl fields and the reviewer workflow, our E-E-A-T and authority building service covers that work, and the healthcare SEO guide sets it in the wider programme.

Filed undersearch quality rater guidelines YMYLYMYL medical websiteGoogle rater guidelines healthcareE-E-A-T hospital website auditLowest quality medical page

About the author

Co-Founder & CTO · Gurugram, India

Arush builds the systems the rest of the company runs on — the patient-acquisition pipelines, the AI chatbots, the analytics that tie a single click to a booked appointment. If a campaign reports a number, it's because something his team built is tracking it.

Free guide · 15 pages

The Patient Acquisition Blueprint

A 90-day plan from first search to booked appointment.

The Pioneers Brief — one essay, three benchmarks, one teardown, every Thursday. Subscribe free →

Free seo audit

Your next chapter starts with a conversation.

Three quick questions. We come prepared with a plan for your specialty and city.

  • A 30-minute call with a healthcare specialist
  • Your top three growth opportunities, in writing
  • Honest advice — even if that means not hiring us
  • No obligation and no hard sell
You’ll speak with a senior strategist
Consultations are hosted by Arush Thapar’s team.
Step 1 of 3Takes 30 seconds

What do you want to improve first?

Details stay privateNo obligationReply within 1 working day

Client portfolio · SEO & search visibility

Work relevant to what the search quality rater guidelines actually say about.

Explore client work →